Nat Qu
I love this movie, and in my eyes it deserves the full 10 stars. I sometimes re-watch it and it is as enjoyable as the first time. I remember that, watching it for the first time, I didn't know what genre it was going to be, so it started as a war movie, and I was thoroughly amazed by the plot twist (when strange things started happening). I think the plot is great, and it is very well done: the mystery buildup, the characters, several twists. On the technical side, I love the sound in this movie - it's a good soundtrack, and the sound effects are done well. And the actors played well too. All in all, one of my favorite movies. For people who read the reviews to check how scary a movie is - I will say, when you watch it for the first time, it gets pretty spooky. There are a few jump scares. It's not gory. It is a good mystery with a dramatic element that is as important as its thrill factor.
MalcolmSouter
So, should you give up a couple of hours and watch this film. If you're one of those people that are happy to chat with everyone around you while watching films or laugh at parts that are meant to be touching or scary, then no. (Okay, don't get me started on that.) If not, you'll enjoy this film, you'll enjoy the acting and you'll enjoy the atmosphere and the tension. I think the 6.? score is to be honest down to people who'd rather watch a documentary on WW II. Yes the submarine seems a bit roomy at times but that doesn't spoil the drama for me. As for the plot, without giving anything away, the sin at the heart of the story grows larger and darker. I won't say any more, just that you'll see some good actors here that have popped up and become more famous 10 years after this film.
mrmac-1
Much underrated (although you don't trust me, I spent a few years on the planet, and am very picky). Truly great scary story. So I came back to edit, and it is to say that this story is, rhyme, understated. Film is your bedtime story come to life. Film is an eclectic medium, taking from all the arts except perhaps the tactile, and who knows how long before we will be able to feel the story physically by literally touching it."Below" is rather poetic, in the sense that it presents a "normal" war story in the context of what war signifies, its meaning and affect on us, yet places the characters in a situation that does not involve war as much as it does the simple unknowns of life. The demon, the ghost here, might very well be the "enemy," in this case the Germans, yet the art is in using this as a metaphor for our process of dealing with felt generalized fear. Of each other, of chaos, of death, of the devil, of God, of candy, slugs, spiders? Up to you. Still, I think, it is always what we think of as our demise, death.But "physical" isn't currently the question. This film has elements of Hitchcock, in that it provides an invitation to look into the mirror that reflects back our emotional life, and asks each of us to make our own decisions. And because of the supernatural/paranormal elements, it touches on what I perceive as something spiritual. Bottom line, it involves us in the character and experiences of the players.War, ghosts, a presence, an intimation, sensitivity, a sense. We do have a problem with death, many of us. This story is about dying in a can, that is, what they tell us about all these things, death, how to do this or that, like live one's life, failed relationships, wanting to do more than you think you are doing, or survival outside, or rather, no matter what your situation, whether you're sinking or floating or on solid earth, you will be asked, at some point, and like the characters in this story, to make a simple "yes" or "no" decision as to how much you appreciate life. It involves that leap of faith that we, some of us, hope to make, amidst a bit of doubt and sadness, and some appreciation of life.Very well filmed, quite well acted, an intriguing and expansive story. It is a bit dark, but that's what leads us to the light.Think about how much you judge.Greg Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (home, btw, of the first nickelodeon theater)
