Dirtylogy It's funny, it's tense, it features two great performances from two actors and the director expertly creates a web of odd tension where you actually don't know what is happening for the majority of the run time.

Kirandeep Yoder The joyful confection is coated in a sparkly gloss, bright enough to gleam from the darkest, most cynical corners.

Tymon Sutton The acting is good, and the firecracker script has some excellent ideas.

Guillelmina The film's masterful storytelling did its job. The message was clear. No need to overdo.

cmcastl This film has been undeservedly overshadowed by that other classic British film on the supernatural 'Dead of Night'.Efficiently directed by Leslie Norman, who gets good performances out of all the actors, it is that best of supernatural films, a film about ideas and characters caught up in an increasingly mysterious, ominous and threatening situation rather than a conventional ghost or horror story, or collection of such stories as in Dead of Night'. The scripting is excellent, as it should be from the pen of RC Sheriff who wrote the classic WWI story Journey's End. It is fascinating to learn that the inspiration for the film was an actual premonition recounted by a senior RAF officer Victor Goddard.The true film about the supernatural is my view a film not so much about ghosts or demons but about ideas and philosophical concepts as the characters find themselves locked into a supernatural drama of Fate over which they realise with mounting unease, even fear they have no control. That a dream which was recounted at a party with which they all become familiar - the gradual revelation to each of them is nicely paced - may be presaging the fatal air crash in which they may all perish.Most of the characters are the British at their most famously pragmatic; the Air Marshal (stolidly played by Michael Redgrave, for the most part, but who himself gives a marvellous suggestion of barely controlled hysteria towards the end of the film as he tries to order the captain of the doomed flight to go against the latter's better judgement as to how to handle a crash landing), the pilots, the young lady secretary, the aide to the Air Marshal (played by Denholm Elliott in a nicely judged performance subtly suggesting how his character, as a former Battle of Britain pilot, is suffering from what later would be called post-traumatic stress disorder). Underneath, however, you sense in each of them a backstory in which given sufficient prodding by fate as occurs in this story their characters would inevitably begin to betray doubts as whether to the world which they usually inhabit is quite as they would like to believe. That the British stiff upper lip and lack of imagination has its limits. There is a marvellous saying by the British scientist J.B.S. Haldane I would like to quote here. "I have a suspicion that the world is not only stranger than we conceive but stranger than we can conceive." Alexander Knox is particularly effective as the outwardly rational Civil Servant who is repressing inner demons, possibly created or exacerbated by his time as a POW, which increasingly cause him to feel, as the dream unfolds, that he is hardly in control of his own life. Michael Hordern is excellent value as the dreamer of the dream whose recounting of which at the party, sets the whole plot in motion. Hordern manages to slyly suggest something supernatural about his character, even though he is an officer in the British Navy, something of what they call in mythology 'the trickster spirit'.

mezzipops The story begins to draw you in as commander Lindsay (Michael Hordern) relates a recent dream he has had about an air crash involving certain members of a dinner party he has cordially been invited to.Gradually, his dream starts to turn to a nightmarish reality as events start coming true. Even the Air Marshall played by Michael Redgrave, usually in control, finds his "stiff upper lip" starting to quiver as the dreaded dream of an air disaster looks like becoming a reality.Mr Robertson (Alexander Knox)gives a convincing performance as a man terrified of flying but more afraid of being seen to let his fear override his ideas of being dominated by superstition.This gripping story makes comparisons between the Eastern beliefs in dreams and omens and the Western culture's dismissive attitude to the same."There is no effect without cause" and this clever film has a way of persuading you that you are flying on the ill-fated Dakota instead of sitting comfortably in your armchair. An array of different characters and a fantastic supporting cast including the late Alfie Bass. Great story, superb direction from Leslie Norman, wonderful atmospheric music. In fact the perfect ingredients for a British classic thriller. Unforgettable film, a definite must watch. 10 stars. from Meryl Heasman (songwriter) CATFLAP MUSIC Kent England.

steve-raybould The seediness of the post-war colonial Far East and that rather morbid fascination with death and fate that pervades the consciousness of people who have been through a world-shattering conflict flavours this film. A great script (by RC Sherriff of 'Journeys End' fame) and a great cast - headed by that master of actorly understatement, Micheal Redgrave - slowly build the story, bit by bit. The exotic setting, where strange things could happen. The drab ordinariness of military outposts - which hightens the surreality of the events. A sense of a military and aristocratic world giving way with poor grace to the brash 'modern' future - epitomised by the crass Brummagem scrap dealer (accompanied by his effete elderly public-school personal assistant). The sense of dread is created by the pure spoken word and performance - of a good tale well-told. MR James in the age of Dakotas.

traceyames17 I saw the movie for the first time only two days ago (12/01/2002) and really liked it. For a black & white movie, it had a good story line, suspense and a good selection of characters. It was typically British as in The Dam Busters and Reach For The Sky, bt then again, somethings the British do better than America. Its a movie I could watch again. It also shows a young Denholm Elliott, still highly recognizable as the same person who starred in the Indiana Jones Movies.Very enjoyable and highly recommended.