Smartorhypo Highly Overrated But Still Good

Matialth Good concept, poorly executed.

Bluebell Alcock Ok... Let's be honest. It cannot be the best movie but is quite enjoyable. The movie has the potential to develop a great plot for future movies

Donald Seymour This is one of the best movies I’ve seen in a very long time. You have to go and see this on the big screen.

lalitrudra The only reason, i watched god awful acting in so called side stream script was because i too loved someone named Aditi (stupid, i know). i had high hopes from Imran khan and rest of the crew. there was no good character build up. i agree that it was meant to be light hearted but that does not mean they get the freedom of ruining what could be a masterpiece with their sloth. why was there even a hype when this piece of crap came out. its the same old Bollywood movie which is dreaming to be cinema but fails miserably.

Meghal Welcome to that magical Bombay city, where everybody is rich and can afford magnificent houses with lawns (not flats), where even a son of a widowed mother (vidhava maa ka eklauta beta - Naseer Hussain special) can afford to go to a night club, where horses and carriages roam freely on streets, where characters hangout in suburb but go to a night club in downtown, where the roads are deserted at night and hero has the courage to escort the heroine at midnight near the deserted library (near Fort), where being artist means growing a beard, wearing an earring and uttering absurd dialogues, where the security at international airport is so lax that anybody can run to the departure gate and sing a song without getting shot, where the characters do not have to worry about finding a job after they graduate. The only upset one can face in life is a break-up from love one.Nasir Hussain movies are always about escapist entertainment and Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na is no different. In 60s, it was Asha Parekh and Joy Mukherjee dancing to OP Naiyyar music in hill stations, now you have Imraan Khan and Genelia dancing to ARR's music in Bombay. The director has tried hard to add glitz and glamour and modern day touch to an age old story, but the soul remains the same.There is nothing new in the story. Girl and boy are already together. By the time they realise that they are in love, it is too late. So the chase begins..Considering the fact that Mansoor Khan and Aamir Khan are credited as producers of this movie, it is disappointing to see them following a time-tested safe formula. Music by A R Rehman is top notch, but the songs are ill-placed in the movie and tend to hamper the flow of story. The only saving grace comes in form of Naseeruddin Shah and Ratna Pathak, although I was never able to figure out the Ratna Pathak's exact occupation - is she a social worker? A human right activist? A lawyer?A 6.5/10 - just for the music, pretty faces and the polished look of the movie.

piyush_mehrotra2001 Its no surprise that this movie carries u away to a different world of "meon" n "ratz". The producer himself is Mr perfectionist, Aamir Khan and the music by the music maestro Rehman.. And if this wasn't all then the brilliant acting done by Imraan and also by Genelia D'Souza makes this movie to deserve 10/10... i wonder if anybody can point out to any scene and say "this could have been better" I real lyf Pappu(as described in the movie as non dancer) will also not be able to stop his feet on the tunes of the movie. The youth is no doubt liking the movie and so the children and the adults. In the end as everyone knows-The movie ROCKS!!!!

drhsbedi Fantastic movie ! Gets 10 out of 10. The characters are all very real and likable . The humor is rollicking - eg the policeman saying ' We have caught the terrorist and he is saying Meow , Meow ! ' was too good. The role of the brother - Amit - played by Babbar was a great one. The young Babbar seems to have a great potential and we should be seeing more of him . Paresh Rawal is at his usual best. Naserrudin Shah steals the show in his short but memorable performance. Ratna Pathak is a welcome comeback. Who played the man holding the placard 'Mr Godot' in the very last scene at the airport arrival ?? Was it Aamir ?