Alicia I love this movie so much

KnotMissPriceless Why so much hype?

Jeanskynebu the audience applauded

TaryBiggBall It was OK. I don't see why everyone loves it so much. It wasn't very smart or deep or well-directed.

zetes On the opposite side of the disc for 3 Bad Men, I figured it was short and I might as well cross it off my John Ford list. Not worth the time. The story here is just boring, and, though it's interesting to see Victor McLaglen in a silent role and John Wayne as an extra (this was his first film appearance, and that's probably what the film is best known for), it's one of Ford's worst. McLaglen is supposedly the star, but he's mostly a side character. The main story revolves around a love triangle. June Collyer is the daughter of a notorious judge who sentenced many people to the gallows. Her father insists she marry a rich man (Earle Foxe) to ward off his bad reputation, but she's in love with Larry Kent. McLaglen plays a mysterious figure from Foxe's past who shows up to expose his own evil history. Wayne appears as a spectator at a horse race who gets so excited he breaks the fence in front of him. I admit I fell asleep about ten minutes before the end of this one but wasn't interested enough to go back and finish it.

Michael_Elliott Hangman's House (1928) *** (out of 4) John Ford directed this melodrama about an infamous hangman judge who's on his death bed when he asks his daughter (June Collyer) not to marry the man she loves (Larry Kent) but instead marry a man (Earle Foxe) who isn't any good but carries a certain social flame. As it turns out, this man is responsible for the suicide of a woman who just happens to have a brother (Victor McLaglen) who sets out for revenge. Once again Ford perfectly captures the mood, feel and atmosphere of the Ireland settings and makes a very fast paced film. The movie is mainly melodrama but there's an added touch of what would eventually become known as Gothic Horror. The creepy house used in the film is something you'd expect to see in a Euro Horror film as it really becomes its own vital character. The visuals are great throughout and really add to the dread of the situations and the entire cast shines in their roles. Foxe makes for a great villain with Kent a likable and sympathetic character. McLaglen steals the show as the brother who will stop at nothing to get vengeance. The finale contains some great stunts with the climax clearly being the highlight of the film. There's a scene here, which Ford would later use in The Quiet Man and we also get a clear view of a young John Wayne during one scene.

MartinHafer This early John Ford film is set in one of his favorite locales--Ireland. And, in so many ways, it looks like a Ford film--the dress, the scenery, the pacing and the loving and idyllic way it portrays the Old Country.Oddly enough, the film is highly reminiscent of the later award winning Ford film, THE INFORMER, though this time Victor McLaglen plays a brave hero and Earle Foxe plays the coward. And, also rather odd, is that there are really two male heroes in the film--as Victor is befriended by Larry Kent. Both men hate the man played by Foxe and the movie is a long buildup until the final ultimate showdown. The actual demise of this horrid man is handled very well, as it is now as you would normally expect! For a silent film, this is a well directed and acted film (without over-dramatics like some silents). Not great, but certainly one of the better examples of the era.By the way, thank you to the perceptive reviewers who noticed John Wayne as an extra at the race scene. He is clearly visible but you've really gotta look close and pay attention!

Single-Black-Male Having worked as a 'grip' during his summer holidays between terms at the University of Southern California, John Wayne was given the opportunity to rub shoulders with John Ford in this film as an extra. When Wayne sustained an injury to his shoulder, Ford suggested to him to work full-time in films.