Moustroll Good movie but grossly overrated

Glucedee It's hard to see any effort in the film. There's no comedy to speak of, no real drama and, worst of all.

Verity Robins Great movie. Not sure what people expected but I found it highly entertaining.

Quiet Muffin This movie tries so hard to be funny, yet it falls flat every time. Just another example of recycled ideas repackaged with women in an attempt to appeal to a certain audience.

rajandey U me aur hum is a classic in my eyes. The film did average business commercially. But I think 90% of whoever has seen the film loved the film out and out. U me aur hum, sure it has something that the Notebook also has. The film is about alzheimer's in love. That CERTAINLY Doesn't MEAN THAT "U ME AUR HUM" IS A REMAKE OF THE NOTEBOOK!!Everything is optimal in this movie, be it direction-wise, performance-wise, art-wise, song-wise, casting-wise! I always thought Ajay Devgan is very very underrated. Hopefully this movie will change his careerline! Gosh what a storyteller, the way he pours emotions in his characters, the way he uses the camera, the way he has chosen the locations. Everything exceeds! U me aur hum is Ajay's finest work as an actor, and of course a VERY powerful debut as a director. Kajol is perfect! She shares 1000% awesome chemistry with Ajay. Both her and Ajays performances sometimes make your eyes water.Songs are excellent! Be it Dil Dhakda, Jee le, Phatte, Saaiyaan or the U me aur hum tracks. Beautiful. This film is truly a masterpiece! Way to go ajay!

kishorekunal2000 What a movie Ajay has made!! Absolutely great marvelous...... It was Without any doubt an amazing job fulfilled by him just like his fellow Amir khan,both jumped in the field of direction and gave the industry a New hope.although it is a remake of Hollywood movie THE NOTEBOOK.But such a great story deserves to be in bollywood not only in bollywood i would say in each and every film making industry because love remains love everywhere,everything else changes.As i realized this is a unique kind of movie based on love,no villains No more family problems bla bla bla......... This movie just circles Around the relationship between a husband and his wife ,the Relationship which started from love and ended with love,love was the Thing which kept them strong even in worse situations.I would like to say this movie is a good tool for bringing back your Girlfriend if she is going away,a rather easy method to add a spark to Your diminishing love life.only thing you have to do is you have to Take her to the theater anyhow….and then i am sure she will be yours so Hurry this offer is valid for a limited period.

gudiya68 I wouldn't call this movie a must watch, but if you've got nothing to do for a couple of hours.... Kudos for picking such a difficult topic as Alzheimer's as still many people don't understand this disease. Lots of copying from The Notebook,but I don't really mind watch Bollywood remakes, however for this film it might have been better if they just did a scene by scene copy bollywood style. A good effort from the Devgan's,unfortunately the love story just wasn't believable for me. Ajay and Kajol looked great together, but they're aging. The acting wasn't too bad, but when your don't have good dialogue it doesn't matter. It would have been better showing them falling in love after an arranged marriage, instead of the whole love at first sight thing. Boring scenes when Ajay looks through Piya's scrapbook and the film shows choppy childhood scenes which were pointless. Also the whole salsa dancing scenes were painful to watch and what was up with the kid who stalks them on the boat? Not nearly enough scenes of normal life after marriage. I found the camera work to be annoying like others have said. Lots of weird close ups (I mean I could see their pores!!). Usually the first half of bollywood films are more fun to watch, but not here, the second half of this one is much better than first. I really liked the supporting characters a lot and would have liked to see more developed stories there since they open the film. Divya Dutta is always a joy to watch. She should do more films. ps. I liked the guy who said "he felt like ripping his arm out and bashing his head" - hilarious, still laughing!!

Chrysanthepop These days in Bollywood, handicap (whether mental or physical) seems to be the trend. Even the popular 'Om Shanti Om' parodies this. After 'Black', 'Maine Gandhi Ko Nahi Maara', 'Fanaa', 'Taare Zameen Par', 'Naina' etc, we have 'U, Me Aur Hum' and the only film that stands out is 'Maine Gandhi Ko Nahi Maara' followed by 'Taare Zameen Par' to an extent. So what's wrong with 'U, Me Aur Hum'? Well, there's too many wrongs in this one.The screenplay is inconsistent, imbalanced and exaggerated. The writing is just so bad that some of the dialogues make one cringe. The Ajay-Piya before-marriage love story is both unconvincing and uninteresting thanks to the terrible writing. The scenes on the ship are boring. It does remind one of 'Mann' (a movie which I liked except for the ripoff part) but the Ajay-Kajol chemistry does not match up to what Aamir and Manisha had (in addition 'Mann' had some very good dialogues). Most of the jokes and 'one-liners' fail to make an impression. While in the post-interval portion when one would expect things to get better as the story takes a drastic turn, things are too exaggerated.The camera-work is both overused and misused. Why were scenes being shot from a strange angle? The close-ups were irritating as they were pointlessly in-your-face. The CGI is terrible AND it is excessively overdone. The songs are forgettable. Most of them are better forgotten. The salsa sequence is terrible (the horrendous cinematography does not help here) and some of the backup dancers were laughable.As a director Ajay Devgan fails to put it all together. He should have hired a better writer and written something better himself (since he's credited as writer). His film looks very messy. As an actor he's average. Watch Jim Broadbent in 'Iris' to see an amazing performance and compare that to Ajay's (both are similar roles). Kajol too gives an inconsistent performance which is overall average. It does not rank among her best. The supporting cast don't leave a mark. Isha Shervani is there to say a sentence or two and to remind us of how flexible she is. Divya Dutta hams in the beginning but is gradually okay.Devgan may have had good intentions and in some scenes it is apparent that he really tried to do well. Acting and directing is a tough task and only few talented people manage to pull that off. Sadly that isn't the case for Mr. Devgan. And why is it that in most (if not all) Hindi films, healthcare institutes are shown as this cold indifferent lonely place? Yes, support from family and friends is important but sometimes people do need to be admitted to institutes where they can be taken better care of because what others provide is really not enough.