Steineded How sad is this?

Numerootno A story that's too fascinating to pass by...

Aneesa Wardle The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.

Bob This is one of the best movies I’ve seen in a very long time. You have to go and see this on the big screen.

Richard Chatten One of a number of big-budget, Technicolor productions by the recently rebranded Universal-International with which the new management was attempting with disappointing results to raise their profile with an increased number of ambitious prestige films; which eventually morphed into their run of glossy women's pictures of the fifties. Produced with his usual discernment by Walter Wanger, directed by veteran George ('Destry Rides Again') Marshall and ably adapted by Alan Le May from a 1942 novel by James H. Street, 'Tap Roots' was the studio's attempt to make it's own 'Gone With the Wind', with luscious titian-haired Southern tigress Susan Hayward at the centre of some pretty racy dialogue and situations.Ms Hayward is frankly too old for the early scenes (she turned 30 during production and was thus on the verge of becoming the handsome middle-aged grand dame she gracefully matured into over the next fifteen years). But as the film progresses and her character matures her performance grows with her. All the acting is good, particularly Boris Karloff, despite being in blackface as an American Indian (SPOILER WARNING: the film never completely recovers from the almost casual way he gets killed off), and Ward Bond gives one of his best performances in an unusually prominent role in an 'A' feature.

zardoz-13 "Destry Rides Again" director George Marshall's American Civil War saga "Tap Roots" shares more in common with "Gone with the Wind" than "Free State of Jones." "North West Mounted Police" scenarist Alan Le May adapted James Street's 1942 novel about a Southern patriarch, Hoab Dabney (Ward Bond of "The Searchers"), who refuses to embark on war the rest of Mississippi with the Confederacy against Abraham Lincoln. "The Very Thought of You" writer Lionel Wiggam contributed additional dialogue. Since I haven't read Street's novel, I cannot attest to the film's fidelity to the novel. Hoab Dabney has a sprawling plantation style ranch in south central Mississippi that his ancestors carved out of the wilderness. The action unfolds on the eve of the war with everybody dreading the prospect of Lincoln taking up residence in the White House. Oddly enough, the protagonist of this spectacle isn't Hoab Dabney. Instead, newspaper publisher and writer Keith Alexander (a trimly mustached Van Heflin of "The Raid") is the central character. He totes a pair of black powder pistols and he dresses impeccably. Keith has his eyes on Hoab's beautiful, rambunctious daughter Morna (Susan Hayward of "Garden of Evil") who has her eyes glued on American officer Clay MacIvor (Whitfield Connor of "The Saracen Blade"), who hates Lincoln and resigns from the Union Army to become a Confederate officer when hostilities break out. Actually, despite the fact that Jones County native James Street was inspired to write his novel owing to the exploits of Newton Knight, he appears to have been inspired more by Margot Mitchell's "Gone with the Wind." The Newton Knight character Hoab Dabney retreats into the background as a muddled, misguided peripheral character who dominates the action with his refusal to follow Mississippi. The romance between Morna and Clay assumes paramount importance in this Universal-International production. Disaster strikes when Morna is thrown off her horse and injures her spine so badly that Dabney physician Dr. MacIntosh (Griff Barnett of "Santa Fe Stampede") informs everybody that Morna will never walk again. Hoab's close friend, a Native American appropriately named Tishomingo (Boris Karloff of "Frankenstein") rejects MacIntosh's diagnosis and vows to have Morna back on her feet and walking again. Tishomingo believes that relentlessly massaging the leg will restore Morna's ability to perambulate. Meantime, a disillusioned Clay strikes up a romance with Hoab's other daughter, Aven (Julie London of "Nabonga"), and Keith spots them pitching woo. Naturally, Keith moves in on Morna, but she initially rebuffs his advances. Eventually, and inevitably, these two will be drawn together, while Clay shed his blue uniform for a gray one, and Hoab decides to withdraw from the Confederacy. Clay is ordered to arrest Hoab, and Hoab assembles an army, but the Confederates have them surrounded and cut off from the outside world so that Keith cannot get a caravan of arms and ammunition through after the rainy season sets in and turns everything to mud. Marshall and his scenarists carefully set up the dramatic oppositions with Clay emerging as the chief villain and Keith as the steadfast hero. After Clay and his combined Confederate artillery and cavalry attack, Hoab staggers about in a daze when explosions rip his own plantation style ranch apart and this militia scrambles into the swamps. Despite the lack of historical accuracy and the "Gone with the Wind" template, "Tap Roots" isn't a bad movie, merely a formulaic one, but what is particularly galling is that the Confederacy is triumphant in the end when Jefferson Davis' minions were not so in reality. Hoab employs a "Gone with the Wind" maid, Dabby (Ruby Dandridge of "Cabin in the Sky") who does everything out of the goodness of her heart. Marshall does generate suspense and excitement during the final half-hour as it looks like Clay will wipe out Hoab's men despite Keith's best efforts. Universal-International looks like the studio blew a bundle on this Civil War epic. As somebody pointed in the goofs section, mountains can be seen rearing up in the background, and Mississippi has no mountains. Initially, I thought that they might have been pine-clad hills. The photography is excellent as are the performances and the lush production values.

jjnxn-1 Half backed shenanigans down plantation way. A story of a wealthy family of farmers who wish to remain separate from the insanity of the Civil War and the fiery minx who is the eldest daughter of said family.More interesting for what it represented to its leading lady than for how the film turned out. When Susan Hayward landed in Hollywood after being spotted in a magazine advertisement she was still Edythe Marrenner a green kid from Brooklyn who along with a flock of other young hopefuls tested for the role of Scarlett O'Hara in Gone With the Wind. Obviously she didn't get the part and if you've ever seen her test it's obvious she was nowhere near ready. However it planted the seed for her desire to if not play Scarlett then at least play a Southern belle. Within a short time she was discovered by producer Walter Wanger who recognized her potential and through the years carefully cultivated her career eventually making the film which won her the Oscar, I Want to Live! Along the way, about a decade after her initial GWTW test, Wagner developed this mint julep mediocrity for her to fulfill her dream. The thing is it's an odd choice to achieve that goal. Her character, the interestingly named Morna Dabney, after making a memorable entrance disappears for great swathes of the film's running time, first through infirmity and then being removed from the main action of the story for most of the climax. When the camera does train itself on her she is breathtaking, at the peak of her beauty in gorgeous Technicolor but the script hands her a confused character to play, one minute pining for the lout who runs off with her hussy of a sister, a young and lovely Julie London who is given little to do, the next passionate about Van Heflin playing another murkily defined role. Around the edges of the story are Boris Karloff ludicrously cast as an Indian and Ward Bond who by the end is hamming it up to the nth degree.This is beautifully produced but a moderate affair. However for fans of Miss Hayward it's worth watching once but she has many much better movies in her filmography.

whpratt1 I was able to tape this film years ago. It is not often seen on TV and a true classic film. Tap Roots takes place at the outbreak of the Civil War, Lebanon Valley tries to secede from the state of Mississippi and remain neutral. Hating slavery, its leader, Hoab Dabney(Ward Bond), and a faithful Indian friend of the family, Tishomingo(Boris Karloff), promise to protect the valley against the Confederate army. There is a great cast of actors namely: Susan Hayward, Van Heflin and Julie London(former wife of Jack Webb, Dragnet T.V) Tap Roots is rather long and drawn out. However, the plot has romance, excellent photography of the Civil War costumes, sex situations and the action is of great value. Karloff is excellent as an Indian guide of the family and his make-up makes him look just like a Native American. I noticed the Smoky Mountains located in North Carolina and Tennessee where this Mississippi story was filmed which is magnificent to view.