Listonixio Fresh and Exciting

RipDelight This is a tender, generous movie that likes its characters and presents them as real people, full of flaws and strengths.

Bob This is one of the best movies I’ve seen in a very long time. You have to go and see this on the big screen.

Geraldine The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.

Kirpianuscus A good film. amusing, well acted, reflecting, in inspired manner the univers of adults and the world of teenagers. but , in its second part, unrealistic. or forced. or expression of a too hard effort to create a clear genre to film. because something is in unfair place. the kiss is predictable. but the after scenes are not realistic. something missed for define it as the nice short film who you expect.

Havan_IronOak I guess that the coming out experience will be an evergreen subject for gay film makers but this is far from the best version of this story I've seen. The dialogue here could have used a lot of work. While the premise is fun and the film isn't too cringe-inducing, there could have been a lot more innuendo between the boys and the parent's dialogue could have been more related to what the boys were saying. If the one boy HAD come out to his parents just the previous day, there should have been some evidence of that in the parents' conversation and there wasn't. Just for laughs compare this to Boychick (2001) which is readily available on you-tube. It may just be my experience with Jewish mothers but the mother in that rings a lot truer despite the films being more than a decade older.

Horst in Translation (filmreviews@web.de) "Shabbat Dinner" is a 14-minute short film from 2012, which means this one will have its 5th anniversary next year. The writer and director is Michael Morgenstern and this is probably his most known work. Let me start by saying that i have no clue what a Shabbat Dinner is, but this is also completely irrelevant in the film's context. The real problem here is, like so many other times with gay-themed short films, the complete lack of realism. A few points: One boy who has his coming-out would be okay. 2 is just too much of a coincidence. Why would the one boy talk to the other about his coming-out? They weren't friends or something. And please don't say he felt that the other boy was gay too. Outside the grown-ups were talking and this was intentionally trivial and bland, but it's also trivial and bland for the audience. Why would a boy who just admitted for the first time that he was a homosexual get busy right away with somebody who is basically a complete stranger. With his parents and the other boy's parents in the next room? Sorry, but I just cannot take this film seriously and shame on the awards bodies who considered it quality filmmaking. I highly recommend to stay away.

Danny G I truly enjoyed Shabbat Dinner. It made me feel strongly. It reminded me how incredibly vulnerable I once felt about my own same-sex attraction. I also felt the same need to hide such an important part of myself from others!There is also plenty of humor in this powerful short film, which given the intensity of the subject matter is much appreciated!I also had the good fortune to meet the director, Michael Morgenstern. He mentioned Shabbat Dinner was his first film! I was amazed! If his first film is this good, I can't wait to see what else he comes up with in the future!