Maleeha Vincent
It's funny, it's tense, it features two great performances from two actors and the director expertly creates a web of odd tension where you actually don't know what is happening for the majority of the run time.
lasttimeisaw
Hailed as Walt Disney of the Soviet Union, this epic fantasy is Ptushko's swan song (he passed away in 1973) and unequivocally his most ambitious work. Based on Pushkin's poem, RUSLAN AND LUDMILA runs 150 minutes, which allows Ptushko to mould an extensively lavish set to minutely fabricate the fairy tale, in a children-friendly fashion. Ruslan (Kozinets), a valiant knight, is going to marry Ludmila (Petrova), the prepossessing daughter of Prince Vladimir of Kiev (Abribosov), but in their wedding night, Ludmila is abducted by an evil dwarf wizard, Chernomor (Fyodorov) who is in alliance with a vengeful witch Naina (Kapnist), so Ruslan is on his way to rescue her, together with three other rivals who are also yearning for Ludmila, they are Rogdai (Mokshantsev), a sully-looking warrior, Ratmir (Akhmetov), a young Khazar Khan and Farlaf (Nevinnyy), a portly gourmand.As a master of stop-motion filmmaking, four decades later, Ptushko's sleights of hand are all the same enthralling to appreciate prominently as a novelty before CGI-era, crude but fantastic, Naina's witchcraft, Chernomor's magic beard, the giant slumbering human head, the wizard's hat which can make people invisible, a crafty juxtaposition of labouring giants and normal-size humans, and the combat between Ruslan and Chernomor in the soaring sky, all can effortlessly take the audience's breath away at that time.Unfortunately, the momentum slumps in the last half-hour, where Kiev is under siege from its barbaric attackers, here, so obvious that Ptushko is not competent to command the large scale of action sequences, the battle scenes are generically haphazard, extras are playing house, and shoddy models are ubiquitous. All the more, the acting, is the simplest type which leaves no trace of subtlety or empathy, fairly straightforward to the degree that every toddler can feasibly comprehend who is good and who represents evil, Ruslan is the invincible hero and Ludmila is the fearless heroine, who can single-handedly fend off Chernomor and his minions with all the pillows on the bed, Naina is the source of evil and Chernomor is merely a jester. It all can be subsumed as the standard Disney franchise, but unfortunately it becomes ever so distracting from adult's eyes. With all due respect to Ptushko and his screw for their laborious effort, a 6/10 is my conscientious vote for this one.
dbborroughs
The film is on two dvds as many Rusico films are. (it has to be the extras) This is not always a bad thing...Here its a bit of a help since the first half is better than the second. To that end a movie review in Two Parts Part One: The film is the story of the title two characters who are in love. Ludmila is kidnapped on her wedding night and the king, angry at the loss of his daughter vows that she will be the bride of who ever returns her.So off the suiters go along with Ruslan in the hope of rescuing the maiden.The culprit is a dwarf with a forty foot long beard.The final film by Aleksandr Ptushko is yet another fairy tale based up the writing of the poet Pushkin.Ptushko is a rather odd filmmaker who spent all of his career churning out odd fairy tales that sold one on the idea of grand Mother Russia.I've seen several of his films now and I'm of mixed opinion of him and his work.He makes films that look like grand fairy tales with lots and lots of everything you expect in said tales but tend to be a bit stilted in direction, coupled with the love of country nonsense he pours into the proceedings his films can be really tough to watch.The first half of this film is one of his better films, very fantastical and fairy tale like.I was watching the film in English with the subtitles on and the dub is almost exactly what the subtitles are which is good. Interesting is the fact that the dub must be from a cut English version of the film since the English drops out periodically to be replaced by Russian.I love the visuals of the film even if the effects leave something to be desired at times. The giants head, the fearsome forest and some of the evil dwarf's lair are beautiful to behold.When the first DVD ended I was looking forward to the second part of the film.Part two. Oh dear god this is horrible.The first half is a decent film but the second half seems longer than its 70 minutes by six or seven hours.The first half of the film ended with Ruslan getting the sword that could defeat the evil Dwarf. The second half is a bunch of beautiful to look at but badly acted tableaux of an evil witch attempting to stop Ruslan from getting to the dwarf's lair.When he gets there and defeats the dwarf almost an hour remains...I think I was stunned into disbelief.He then goes off with an unconscious Ludmila...Then things get wonky as the Mongols attack and Ruslan dies... for awhile.The Final attack on the castle is one of the wost battle scenes ever put on the screen ever. I MEAN EVER!!!!! Heads fly and people are cut in half and its badly acted as arrows go three feet, a cow is shot full of arrows and the dialog is laughably bad....The second half of this film is an unmitigated bomb. Its one of the worst films ever made.Watch the first half, avoid the second.4 out of 10 over all
plamya-1
Those who order this film expecting faithfulness to the Pushkin mock folk-epic should be aware that the structure owes more to the ancient bylina tradition than to Pushkin's sophisticated play with language and literary tradition. Here Ludmila is the daughter of Prince Vladimir of Kiev, and Ruslan is a more successful version of Prince Igor of the medieval tale. While it is a good "also-ran" in the folk-tale- fairytale film market, it is a long way from capturing the kind of following that, say, the "Wizard of OZ" has in film. A modern viewer will find it difficult to overlook the dated techniques of the film's special effects.
Raymond Tucker
Wow. What a film. The more I see of Ptushko's work, the more I admire his wild imagination. There are beautiful visuals throughout such as the wizard's crystal garden or the upside down ceiling mounted fountains spewing multicolored water. There are also bizarre scenes such the gigantic head that advises Ruslan or the climactic duel where Ruslan hangs from the 30 foot long beard of a flying midget. A must-see for any fan of The Day the Earth Froze (Sampo) or Magic Voyage of Sinbad (Sadko) This came highly recommended to me by a friend who'd seen it at a film festival, and I was not disappointed.
