BoardChiri Bad Acting and worse Bad Screenplay

Merolliv I really wanted to like this movie. I feel terribly cynical trashing it, and that's why I'm giving it a middling 5. Actually, I'm giving it a 5 because there were some superb performances.

Juana what a terribly boring film. I'm sorry but this is absolutely not deserving of best picture and will be forgotten quickly. Entertaining and engaging cinema? No. Nothing performances with flat faces and mistaking silence for subtlety.

Rexanne It’s sentimental, ridiculously long and only occasionally funny

corporalko This is a different Gene Autry film, not featuring either a lot of music or a lot of action. That's why I gave it only an "8" instead of a "10." But the complaining some other reviewers did about "Where's Robin Hood?" was explained by the first review posted above. It was a phrase often used by Republic Pictures to identify a movie in which the hero has to defy the "powers that be" in order to catch the bad guys and return the working people's money that has been stolen -- as Gene does in this film about a bank robbery in which he and his partners, the Cass County Boys, are accused (unfairly) of being "accomplices." A series of coincidences leads Autry and the Cass County Boys to a dude ranch they set up on property inherited by one of the Boys. The "bad guys" who robbed the bank, one by one show up there, thinking the money they stole has been hidden on the ranch, and so does an undercover police officer who still believes Gene and the Boys were somehow "in cahoots" with the crooks.While there is not very much action in the film as a whole, the climactic scene involves a hell-for-leather pursuit of the two remaining bad guys by Gene on Champ, and a fist fight among the three aboard a barreling, two-up farm wagon.An element not mentioned by any other review I've read is the amoral evil of the bank robbers -- attractive men (and one woman), well-dressed, but with absolutely no compunction about killing each other off in order to make off with the entire load of swag.All in all, a good, and different, Gene Autry flick. Sometimes "different," IS good.

dougdoepke There's a slam-bang finale with-- surprise, surprise-- some good rear-projection. Usually, a matinée production's got the rear-projection going one speed while the horse or buckboard goes another. Not here. Anyhow, Gene and crew start up a dude ranch, even while the cops think they've robbed a bank. Meanwhile, the real baddies show up, except they're even meaner to each other than to Gene. It's a more complex screenplay than usual, playing more like a modern crime drama than an oater. Frankly, too much so for my liking, plus too much time is spent indoors rather than out. Nonetheless, the bad guys really are a convincing lot, while there're two eye-candy girls instead of just one. Holloway does comic relief, but in a less annoying way than usual. On the whole, it's a rather odd Autry oater, his last for Republic. His new studio, Columbia, would provide a big production boost. Good!A "5" on the matinée scale.

classicsoncall With no sidekick to speak of, Gene Autry teams up with the Cass County Boys in a fairly standard oater where they're arrested as accomplices in a bank robbery, but are then let off the hook, presumably to lead the authorities to the rest of their gang. They head off to Serenity, Texas and nearby Hidden Valley, where Cass County member Jerry (Jerry Scoggins) has inherited a ranch along with his sister Virginia (Lynne Roberts). With little money and bills coming due, Gene hits on the idea of turning the spread into the Serenity Rest Ranch, a place where harried city folk can go to find some peace and quiet.What passes for the comedy relief in the picture is handled by Sterling Holloway doing a hypochondriac gimmick. His character Droopy Haynes gets entirely flustered if he's overdue a medication or misses ten o'clock bedtime by more than a minute. For some reason I always liked seeing Holloway in these stories when I was a kid, so catching him in this one today on Encore Westerns was a welcome treat.What's somewhat different about this picture is that once the story focuses on the bad guys, they wind up having a fall out over the hundred grand they robbed to open the picture. Duke Mantel (James Cardwell) robs his partners at gunpoint, and wouldn't you know it, heads for Hidden Valley for his own version of rest and relaxation. When the rest of the outlaws catch up with him, it's curtains for Duke, while the remaining hoods continue to battle it out among themselves.By my count there were only four songs in this Western, unusual for an Autry flick where he often got in as many as nine tunes between himself and his supporting cast. Except for serenading Miss Virginia once, all the rest were done with the Cass County Boys providing backup. The one thing I kept thinking about while watching this one was the name of that villain Duke Mantel. I wondered if it might have been inspired at all by Humphrey Bogart's character in the 1936 film "The Petrified Forest". Bogey was a bank robber in that one, and he went by the name of Duke Mantee.

Michael O'Keefe This Republic Picture has Gene Autry and the Cass County Boys accused of bank robbery. To prove their innocence, Gene and the boys are used as decoys to find the missing money. A dude ranch is renovated and who is among the first to check into the Serenity Ranch; dudes for sure, two rival groups of gangsters with two purposes...to hideout and search for the stolen money. Plenty of action; the usual fisticuffs, horse and car chases plus Gene and the Cass County Boys sing several songs including: "Going Back to Texas" and "The Merry-Go-Round Broke Down".Where is Texas? This oater is filmed in Chatworth, California. To be exact...where is Robin Hood? Among the list of players: Sterling Holloway, Lynne Roberts, Adele Mara, James Cardwell and Ray Walker.