Claysaba Excellent, Without a doubt!!

MoPoshy Absolutely brilliant

StyleSk8r At first rather annoying in its heavy emphasis on reenactments, this movie ultimately proves fascinating, simply because the complicated, highly dramatic tale it tells still almost defies belief.

InformationRap This is one of the few movies I've ever seen where the whole audience broke into spontaneous, loud applause a third of the way in.

dbborroughs Pod moves from the country to Bangkok. there he gets a job at a sardine company, meets Jin a maid with whom he falls in love,and eventually becomes a celebrity because he is the only one in the city with out a tail.(I'm leaving out the white book,the finger, the job shifts, the rain of helmets, the plastic mountain, the royal princess, tails, reincarnation and 9 or 10 other things) Off the wall fantasy romance environmental comedy with music. This is the sort of thing that could never get made in the United States and could only come out of Asia. I don't mean that as a put down, only that outside of the West people are more willing to let movies be what ever they are.At turns charming, surreal, funny and too much this is a very wild movie. It drops you into its own little world and keeps you there. I have no idea how to describe it other than its its own animal and unlike any film that has ever been made outside of Thailand (I've seen some Thai films that are equally loopy). The music is good. the sentiment is sweet. All of the weird things that happen just seem to be taken in stride and its wonderful.It also can be a bit overwhelming. Frankly by the time I put in the second VCD I was getting worn out. Too much whimsy for my taste. Actually its not the whimsy so much as some plot shifts that lengthen the story for no good reason (some of the environmental/Peter plot line seems to just go on) and the film seems to be running not so much in its own time but an allotted time.If you can take the film for what it is and let it sweep over you like a tsunami then you'll probably have a good time. Definitely worth a look for those who hate the run of the mill.

marta2046 I absolutely loved this film! Difficult to describe, but like a cross between AMELIE (France) (without the super expensive CGI), TASTE OF TEA (Japan) and perhaps a bit of CHUNGKING EXPRESS (Hong Kong) (with quieter cinematography instead of Chris Doyle's kinetic style.) So visually rich it can even be enjoyed without subtitles, although what it has to say is important.I can't wait to see this director's other films: TEARS OF THE BLACK TIGER, and particularly THE UNSEEABLE, a supernatural horror that is getting rave reviews.This film was shot on HIGH-DEF, yet looks better that most American films shot on 35mm.It just goes to show that it is not budget that determines a great film, but TALENT, HEART and VISION.

badidosh It's soufflé meets tom yum. The comparisons are inevitable but while Wisit Sasanatieng's "Citizen Dog" ("Mah Nakorn") does seem to have been heavily influenced by Jean-Pierre Jeunet's sleeper "Amelie", this surrealistically delightful Thai comedy has enough merits of its own to set it apart from its French counterpart.Screened as part of the International Film Competition of this year's Cinemanila Film Festival, "Citizen Dog" tells the story of Pod (Mahasamut Boonyaruk), a young country man who moves to Bangkok and ends up working on a sardine cannery. After a freak accident where he loses (and eventually regains) one of his fingers, he quits his job and becomes a security guard for another company where he meets and falls in love with Jin (Saengthong Gate-Uthong), a company maid who's obsessed with romance stories in magazines, and an enigmatic white book written in words no one seems to understand.And what ensues is a movie that, for the most part, knows its essential qualities and plays up to its charming oddity and energetic mood that should suit well to the viewer who knows what s/he's in for. The film's quirky nature can be overbearing at times what with Sasanatieng's script that tends to be inconsistent in some parts. But with such a cheery nature that's eager to please, the end result is nevertheless a fulfilling enchantment. The cinematography and production design introduces Bangkok not as the coarse metropolis I was acquainted with during my stay there earlier this year, but rather a city of eccentric fantasy that lends a euphoric quality to the analogous world it presents. The witty employment of various cinematic tricks and giddy soundtrack keep the tone light.While most of the speaking parts belong to Pen-Ek Ratanaruang as the film's narrator, Boonyaruk effortlessly portrays the lead character's mix of audacity and romanticism. Gate-Uthong ably compliments that with her character's impassive feeling towards Pod. Their characters' fate is as obvious as the film's frivolous traits but you can't help but feel for them anyway.Then again, "Citizen Dog" isn't for everyone. You have to be in the right frame of mind to enjoy its quirkiness and be able to laugh with it. As the film tells us, when you stop looking, the thing you're looking for will find you. Ditto. Let the film do its thing and its charm will sneak its way inside you.

James McNally I saw this film at the 2005 Toronto International Film Festival. I'd heard some buzz around this film, that it was sort of a Thai Amelie. In fact, it's Amelie cranked up to 11. Which is entirely too much. This film is absolutely overstuffed with whimsy. A narrator tells us the story of country boy Pod, who comes to Bangkok to find work and falls in love with Jin. Along the way, he loses and then finds his finger, drives around a chainsmoking talking teddy-bear as well as a man who licks everything, and shares his house with a gecko that has the face of his dead grandmother. If that's not enough, the object of his desire is an obsessive neat freak who carries around a book written in Italian that she can't read. A case of mistaken identity sends her off on an environmental crusade that results in her accumulating a mountain (literally, a mountain) of plastic water bottles. Will this pair find love in the end? Well, by the end, I didn't care that much.The problem was that the visual tricks and whimsy overwhelm the characters, who end up being nothing more than a collection of quirks. The constant voice-over also never really lets the characters tell their own stories, and the romance never feels believable.Sasanatieng is obviously a director of huge talent, and there are quite a few great sight gags and some really original visuals. But there's just far too much of it. It's like eating a whole chocolate cake at one sitting. If he could tone down the trickery a bit, and find a story with real characters, he could one day make a really outstanding film. This isn't it yet, but I hope he does it.