VeteranLight I don't have all the words right now but this film is a work of art.

WillSushyMedia This movie was so-so. It had it's moments, but wasn't the greatest.

Fatma Suarez The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

Cristal The movie really just wants to entertain people.

kurtissebastian That's basically the size of it. I don't know about you but I watch the show because I want to see contestants sing. I want to watch their story ark from start to stardom. But whoever's running the show seems to think that all that side story stuff and trying to tug on hartstrings is what brings the ratings and I think they've got it wrong. Sure we want some side story but it shouldn't be the main story. This is a singing competition not a 'who's had it the hardest' show. So far I've been pretty disappointed with how little singing I've seen. There were a lot of singers I wanted to see more of who they just glossed over or didn't show it all. Like what happened with Carley? I thought she was pretty rad but even if the show creators didn't think so, shouldn't they have shown us something of her Hollywood week performance? If they spent more time showing singers and less time shooting for zingers they could have showcased more talent. If this show doesn't change its format for the next season (if it gets a next season), I see no reason to expect it has a future. Too bad because it's a great concept. The creators need to take a cue from the judges: be yourself. When you try to be something you're not you won't be successful.

nanagodzilla-763-761395 Show business is always connections comes first: it is annoying Gianna Isabella dropped her mother's name before singing at the audition. It would be DISGUSTING if she becomes the winner： Many girls on the show are way better than her.Frankly, she can sing, but anyone who has been training from childhood can sing, her voice is not unique or outstanding. if she has won this, then the show really deserves to be ended： Audience are not idiots, it would be so obviously implanting.During the David Cook season, the media exposed one of the top 24 is heavily connected to the Fox senior executive, after that, that girl was disqualified. So it is a clever strategy to show the connection with JLo in public in the very beginning to avoid the same disqualification happens. Lindita and Sara should be in top 24 instead. The only positive thing I think of Gianna is, at least she does not dress like a teenage slut.

Adrian Val Olonan The show has a nice premise. Search for America's best singers and turn them into singing stars. The show has given us Kelly Clarkson, Jessica Hudson, Clay Aiken, Adam Lambert, David Archuleta, and Jessica Sanchez. These artists are very good with their genres. But Season 7, and the White Guys with Guitars (WGWG) occurred. It started with David Cook and ended with Philllip Phillips. What about exploring different artists of different music genres?Also, I can't believe how this show became desperate to boost TV ratings. Jermaine Jones was eliminated due to ongoing criminal charges against him back in Season 11. He was a black contestant. They filmed him hearing the elimination and his emotional moment. Do we audiences really need another black criminal stereotype to be pushed down our throats? Hell, no! Also, you'll notice that the said season is like a horror movie. The minorities vanish first. Wow!This show will end with a whimper, and it's somehow deserved.

remlawrence i was so glad that they kick Simon out of this show after his poor review in the X factor. the irony for him is that the winner happen to be the person he took out initially..( and put her back ).it goes to show how wise is his "judgement" as for the judges of the American idol i wonder why they still keep the old fashioned ones behind only 1 of them hit the billboard charts?? the others are not..unlike "the voice" where the judges are much more current and credible and all their judges are still "on chart" times have change so...keep up with times bro, American idol.... audience are no longer please with seeing the "candy coating" bring some high-power judges e.g. Lady GaGa... however i must say the production was good, the director did an excellent job here.