Odelecol Pretty good movie overall. First half was nothing special but it got better as it went along.

Maidexpl Entertaining from beginning to end, it maintains the spirit of the franchise while establishing it's own seal with a fun cast

StyleSk8r At first rather annoying in its heavy emphasis on reenactments, this movie ultimately proves fascinating, simply because the complicated, highly dramatic tale it tells still almost defies belief.

Bea Swanson This film is so real. It treats its characters with so much care and sensitivity.

mark.waltz An old vaudeville gag has a wife hiding her lover in her closet as her husband comes home unexpectedly, and when he goes to the closet, the lover claims he's waiting for a streetcar as one arrives in the nick of time. This is nothing more than an almost plotless musical comedy about an American theatrical producer (Jack Benny) in London who accepts the invitation of a neglected wife (Binnie Barnes) to come to her country estate for the weekend to make her husband (Edward Arnold) jealous. He's already upset because the musical comedy star he's in love with (Dorothy Lamour) loves somebody else (Phil Harris). Then there's "Rochester", aka Eddie Anderson, Benny's wise-cracking but loyal valet who gives Mr. Benny as good as it takes. Toss in Betty Grable in a pointless role as a chorus girl and you've got the ingredients for a comical pie where sadly the fruit has been left out.Some lavish production numbers are interspersed, but other than the luxurious art decco look, they are not really all that memorable. The best scenes of course involve Benny and Rochester's interactions, especially a huge meal where the dateless Benny refuses to allow Rochester to partake of it until he is dumped by Lamour and turned down by Grable and her chorus girl friends who would rather spend an evening with their Aunt Tilly than with Jack. The rapporteur between Benny and Robinson might often seem subservient from Rochester's point of view, but it becomes very clear that Benny would be absolutely lost without him and that Rochester is greatly aware of that. Isabel Jeans ("Gigi") and Monty Woolley ("The Man Who Came to Dinner") have inconsequential supporting parts as members of Barnes' and Arnold's social set, with Jeans very comical in her over the top French accent as the instigator of Barnes' deception. Barnes is urbane and sophisticated, and Arnold his usually gregarious self, very funny in a scene where Barnes brags about her lunch with Benny as he basically responds, "That's nice, dear". Of course, when all becomes clear to him, it's a different story, and Arnold spends much of the rest of the film trying to shoot Benny for messing with his wife. Unlike other comics of the time, it appears to me that Benny simply tried to repeat the success of what he was doing on radio, not really thinking that audiences at the movies wanted something more solid than gags and a couple of decent songs. It isn't bad, but I wouldn't call Benny a threat at Paramount to anything his good friend Bob Hope had been doing already.

malcolmgsw I have always been a big fan of Jack Benny.I was looking forward to watching this film but what a letdown.It was desperately unfunny.There was absolutely no chemistry between him and his co stars.The musical numbers were poor and badly staged.The plot seemed to be a feeble rip off of A Damsel In Distress.Who thought that Edward Arnold was suitable casting as an English aristocrat?Jack Benny was very good in situation comedy but not really at physical comedy.The acrobat sequence is an embarrassment.Lamour is lacking any spark,maybe she was at her best in a sarong.The whole mess limps along to an ending that makes no sense at all.So as has been said elsewhere this makes "The Horn Blows at midnight"seem like a minor classic.

ellaf A Jack Benny vehicle, this film is very watchable even after all these years. Jack Benny, though not as funny as he's supposed to be here, does his job well. One feels like putting an arm over his shoulders watching him being so kind with no success to win Dorothy Lamour.Now, Dorothy Lamour...how can someone NOT like her? She's beautiful, exotic looking but at the same time very down-to-earth. She also possesses a beautiful contralto singing voice and has a great acting talent. Her part was supposed to be Betty Grable's at the time, but well, it went to her. So be it...she's great.The beautiful Betty Grable, unfortunately, is not seen very much here. She has a short song, though, but so short you don't even have time to realize she's on the screen displaying her shapely legs and sparkling personality! A SHAME! Watch for Eddie Anderson! He's the real star in this film and immediately steals the show completely! He's funny, totally into his character and so likable. And he does 2 solo dancing numbers.As for the plot, well, it is messy. It seems the producer wanted to put as many actors as he could in one same movie and had many parts written on the corner of a table at the last minute to put them in the movie. The result is not, therefore, always effective. But, even with this fault, the movie stays very watchable and sports a classy looks.See it.

theowinthrop There is a persistent rumor that Jack Benny only made one good film in his career: Ernst Lubitsch's TO BE OR NOT TO BE. Actually, the radio and television comedy star did make other comedies that were worth watching - most notably CHARLIE'S AUNT , IT'S IN THE BAG and LOVE THY NEIGHBOR (both with Benny's radio feud partner Fred Allan), and GEORGE WASHINGTON SLEPT HERE (with Anne Sheridan and Charles Coburn - a kind of dry run for Cary Grant and Myrna Loy's MR. BLANDINGS BUILDS HIS DREAMHOUSE). But he certainly made one or two serious misfires: BUCK BENNY RIDES AGAIN and THE HORN BLOWS AT MIDNIGHT (the last one even Benny realized was awful).MAN ABOUT TOWN was typical of the rut that Benny frequently fell into. Because of his radio personality, the movies rarely thought of experimenting with him in a variety of roles. Different aspects of his cheap tightwad and his narcissistic would-be great lover popped up in many of his films, even his best ones. In MAN ABOUT TOWN he is a musical comedy star and producer in London, playing opposite Dorothy Lamour (whom he is in love with). But she is tired of his finding excuses not to marry her, so she is cold shouldering him. Benny tries to get her back in line by showing too much attention to Binnie Barnes, an English aristocrat. Barnes, upon the advise of Isobel Elsom, reciprocates to make her husband, Edward Arnold, jealous. As is pointed out in another of the reviews, Elsom is determined to reignite her husband's (Monte Wooley) jealousy the same way. Benny is not upset by this development - besides making Lamour smolder (as he hopes) he is getting a lot of publicity for his new show (which has a final musical number where Benny is a potentate with a harem).Arnold and Wooley both are certain that each other is the cuckold here, but when they both realize that both of their wives have been seemingly carrying on with Benny, they both decide to rid the world of him. So while on stage in that final number, Benny sees both men standing side by side with murder in their eyes, and makes a fair shambles of his show's finale. Lamour and Benny's faithful valet/factotum Eddie Anderson save his bacon.It is amusing at points, and besides "Rochester" it is of interest to Benny and old radio fans to see his first "juvenile" singer, Phil Harris, in the film too. But it is little more than a mild amusement. See it once, and that is all there is to it. Amusing but not a film for the ages.